Open Science and research data

Un article de Wiki URFIST.

(Différences entre les versions)
Version du 17 juin 2020 à 14:03 (modifier)
Cercamon (Discuter | Contributions)
(the different types of data)
← Différence précédente
Version du 17 juin 2020 à 14:06 (modifier) (défaire)
Cercamon (Discuter | Contributions)
(parent concepts)
Différence suivante →
Ligne 61 : Ligne 61 :
:[ Michael Nielsen] :[ Michael Nielsen]
-===== parent concepts =====+===== related concepts =====
* "sciences" * "sciences"

Version du 17 juin 2020 à 14:06

original in french: Open Science et données de la recherche

While the issue of open access to scientific publications (Open Access) is about twenty years old, today we are talking about access to the data themselves, about sharing research data. What are the reasons for this shift in scale and what are the issues at stake? Scientific issues, but also economic and legal issues. But first, what are we talking about? What exactly are research data? We will see that there are several kinds, each of which raises specific questions. Finally, we will consider the consequences of this new issue for the researcher's own activity and the question of Data Management Plans (DMP).

Open Science Monitor


First approach: a research and its data

case study (Workshop by Yvette Lafosse and Françoise Cosserat)

-> Tutoriels « Le libre accès aux résultats de la recherche dans le cadre d’Horizon 2020 »

What is "research data"?

> Noëmie Rosemberg, "De la définition des données de la recherche," in En quête des données, le 30/09/2015

definitions (data and validation)

That of the OCDE:

"In the context of these Principles and Guidelines, “research data” are defined as factual records (numerical scores, textual records, images and sounds) used as primary sources for scientific research, and that are commonly accepted in the scientific community as necessary to validate research findings. A research data set constitutes a systematic, partial repre-sentation of the subject being investigated.

This term does not cover the following: laboratory notebooks, pre-liminary analyses, and drafts of scientific papers, plans for future research, peer reviews, or personal communications with colleagues or physical objects (e.g. laboratory samples, strains of bacteria and test animals such as mice). Access to all of these products or outcomes of research is governed by different considerations than those dealt with here.

These Principles and Guidelines are principally aimed at research data in digital, computer-readable format. It is indeed in this format that the greatest potential lies for improvements in the efficient distribution of data and their application to research because the marginal costs of transmitting data through the Internet are close to zero.These Principles and Guidelinescould also apply to analogue research data in situations where the marginal costs of giving access to such data can be kept reasonably low."

The one of the Australian National Data Service:

"Research Data: Data are facts, observations or experiences on which an argument, theory or test is based. Data may be numerical, descriptive or visual. Data may be raw or analysed, experimental or observational. Data includes: laboratory notebooks; field notebooks; primary research data (including research data in hardcopy or in computer readable form); questionnaires; audiotapes; videotapes; models; photographs; films; test responses."

Sylvie Fayet:

"At the very least, we implicitly agree on the following idea: when we talk about "research data", we mean figures, readings, measurements, results of experiments, responses to surveys, statistics, counts, and other quantitative data on the basis of which a hypothesis will be developed, and/or which will be used to invalidate or validate this hypothesis... in short, essentially quantitative data, which can be processed, sorted, exploited, visualized in a homogeneous manner. The publication of such data is already part, at least in some disciplines, of the canons of scientific article writing (for example, the "Materials and methods" section in the recommendations for writing articles in medical journals)".

the different types of data

from the published papers to the data: embedded data, underlying data, raw data... (reverse engineering): embedded data > underlying data > raw data...:

Media:Schema DR 170120.pdf

purposes of sharing research data

  • validation (reproducible science)
  • reuse (cumulative science)

Issues and Context:

Open Science

“Open science is the idea that scientific knowledge of all kinds should be openly shared as early as is practical in the discovery process.”

Michael Nielsen
related concepts
  • "sciences"
    • e-science: e-science / digital
      • "e-documentation" (cf. open access)
        • granularity issues
      • computerization of scientific activity (cf. big data): "ideas like recursion, parallelism and abstraction taken from computer science will redefine modern science. Implicit in the idea of a fourth paradigm is the ability, and the need, to share data. In sciences like physics and astronomy, the instruments are so expensive that data must be shared. Now the data explosion and the falling cost of computing and communications are creating pressure to share all scientific data." (John Markoff)
    • open access [ fr ]
    • Science 2.0
    • Open Science [ fr ]
  • data

Image:LOD Cloud 2014.svg.png[1]

Open Science

[Open Science Monitor]

validation crisis


"The rule is to describe one's work with sufficient precision so that someone else can understand it in all its details, reproduce it, verify, confirm or refute it."

legal and regulatory context


disciplinary variations

Roughly speaking (very roughly) in Humanities and Social Sciences the purpose "reuse" outweighs the purpose "validation". > Text mining

Digital Humanities

disciplinary cultures (some exemples)

Managing and sharing our data

> Faut-il partager ses données?

-> Tutoriels « Le libre accès aux résultats de la recherche dans le cadre d’Horizon 2020 »
  • The Data Management Plan
  • Organazing and describing
  • Storage and conservation
  • Sharing and dissemination

back to the exemple case